UK still struggling to improve bathing water quality

The UK's compliance with EC bathing water standards improved slightly this summer. But it was still below the levels achieved in the mid-1990s, and full compliance with the EC rules looks some years off.

The standards laid down by the 1976 EC Directive on bathing water quality should have been met in 1985. But it was not until 1990 - after water privatisation - that a £2 billion programme was launched to improve coastal sewage discharges and storm overflows affecting designated bathing waters.

All but a handful of major schemes in the programme were due for completion by 1995. But some have slipped behind schedule, while others have proved inadequate to assure compliance with the EC standards.

For England and Wales, the Environment Agency predicted two years ago that 95% of designated waters would meet the mandatory EC standards for coliform bacteria in 1996, with close to a 100% pass rate in 1997. But this autumn it revised the projected pass rate to "at least" 93% in 2000.

Announcing this summer's results, the Department of the Environment, Transport and the Regions (DETR) chose to highlight that "bathing water quality in England this season was the best ever and overall UK results were better than last year."

There was indeed an improvement on last year, with the proportion of UK waters meeting the mandatory coliform limits increasing from 88.3% last year to 88.7% this year. But both these figures were below the pass rates of 91%, 91% and 89.6% achieved in 1994-96.

The compliance rates in the last two years were inflated by the addition of 23 newly designated waters, all of which passed the EC standards. Ten further waters were designated this year, and eight of these also passed. Three waters also moved from the "fail" to the "pass" categories after polluted water samples were disregarded on the grounds of "abnormal weather", as allowed by the Directive.

Performance in most parts of the UK held steady or showed a slight improvement. The overall picture was clouded by substantial deteriorations in Scotland, where the compliance rate was the lowest for ten years, and in the Northumbrian region (see table ).

Compliance with the stricter EC "guideline" standards improved slightly this year, with 173 waters (44.4%) in England and Wales passing compared with 167 last year. The pass rate, though, was still below the 1996 figure of 175.

Other features of this year's results include:

  • A total of 24 waters in England and Wales which met the mandatory EC standards in 1997 slipped out of compliance this year. The figure is similar to those of recent years, and underlines the difficulty of achieving consistent compliance when just two samples breaching the standards out of the 20 taken over a summer push a water into the "fail" category.

  • Half of the 40 waters in England which failed this summer missed compliance by only one out of 20 samples. This is a worse result than last year, when almost two-thirds of the 50 failures in England and Wales missed compliance by one sample.

  • Breaches of the zero standard for enteroviruses are disregarded by the DETR when reporting the compliance rate. According to data on the Agency's web site, 39 (36.5%) of the 107 waters sampled for viruses this summer breached the standard - including, as in previous years, some which met the coliform standards.

  • All nine of the inland bathing waters designated in the UK for the first time this year met the mandatory EC standards.

    The north-west remains the UK's bathing water black spot. North West Water's programme to bring itself into compliance was thrown off course following the failure of modelling work to make accurate predictions of the dispersal and die-off of bacteria discharged from some of its major sewage works and storm overflows. Earlier this year, the company announced plans to spend an extra £100 million on upgrading several sewage works (ENDS Report 277, p 3 ).

    The programme is due for completion in 2000. In the meantime, some of the region's bathing waters continue to experience high levels of sewage pollution. The peak value recorded this year was 110,000 faecal coliforms per 100ml of water off St Anne's North, south of Blackpool - 55 times the EC limit of 2,000/100ml.

    In Scotland, meanwhile, proposals for designating an extra 60 bathing waters have been submitted to a Scottish Office review by local authorities and community groups.

  • Please sign in or register to continue.

    Sign in to continue reading

    Having trouble signing in?

    Contact Customer Support at
    or call 020 8267 8120

    Subscribe for full access

    or Register for limited access

    Already subscribe but don't have a password?
    Activate your web account here