Court quashes Gummer's decisions on urban wastewater Directive

In the first court decision on the 1991 EC Directive on urban wastewater treatment, the High Court has overturned two designations made by the Environment Secretary when implementing the Directive. R v Secretary of State for the Environment ex parte Kingston-upon-Hull City Council and R v Secretary of State ex parte Bristol City Council and Woodspring District Council (Divisional Court, High Court, 26 January 1996) arose out of his decision in May 1994 that the Humber and Severn Bridges represented the outer limits of the two estuaries for the purposes of the Directive. The Court held that he had applied the wrong legal test by taking into account economic considerations in making the designations. The decision implies that secondary treatment of sewage effluent will now be required,

with considerable financial implications for sewerage undertakers and their customers.

Sign in to continue

Sign in

Trouble signing in?

Reset password: Click here


Call: 020 8267 8120

Take a 30-day trial

  • Join ENDS Report now and pay nothing for your first 30-days.



Prices on request

  • Full access to for 12 months
  • Clear and accessible guidance on relevant legislation
  • Integration with ENDS Compliance Manager helping you plan ahead and ensure compliance for your organisation
  • Individual or bespoke multi-user packages available

See all benefits

Need to activate your subscription?
Already a subscriber
If you haven't already, activate your subscription here>>
Company Domain Access
If your company or university has a corporate subscription simply register your email address here to gain access