Tribunal rules in London air quality case

A landmark Upper Tribunal decision has made it easier for the government to withhold information requested under the Environmental Information Regulations

A landmark Upper Tribunal decision has made it easier for the government to withhold information requested under the Environmental Information Regulations.

On 14 February, the tribunal heard an appeal by the environment department (DEFRA) regarding a request for information by the Campaign for Clean Air in London (CAL) and the Information Commissioner’s Office (ICO). The request was made over two years ago.

The tribunal ruled that DEFRA could add or substitute exemptions to avoid disclosing information requested under the freedom of information regime. The ruling followed a precedent set in an unrelated Home Office case heard the same day.

The ruling means DEFRA can continue to argue it was legitimate for it to withhold information on London’s air quality. 

At an earlier First-tier Tribunal hearing, DEFRA had belatedly claimed legal advice privilege, allowing it to withhold information from CAL on air pollution in London (ENDS Report 432, p 20).

When this was rejected, DEFRA appealed and the Upper Tribunal was tasked with deciding the legality of such a late claim.

Had the information been released, it might have influenced the European Commission’s decision to give a conditional extension to the deadline for meeting coarse particulate limits (see p 27).

CAL argues that the public interest in favour of disclosure is overwhelming. Its director, Simon Birkett, said: “This case raises significant issues of law, particularly regarding the interpretation of the Environmental Information Regulations 2004.”

CAL has applied to the Court of Appeal for permission to appeal. The challenge is being made in conjunction with Friends of the Earth.

Related Environmental Services

Powered by ENDS Directory

Compliance Search

Discover all ENDS content in one place, including legislation summaries to keep up to date with compliance deadlines

Compliance Deadlines

Plan ahead with our Calendar feature highlighting upcoming compliance deadlines

Most-read articles

Principal Planner

Leeds is a fast growing city and the main driver of a city region with a £64.6 billion economy.

Officer 2 Environment Team x 2

Sustainable Management of Natural Resources

Environment Team Leader

If you want a role that offers variety and challenge, and to be a part of an organisation that has the sustainable management of natural resources at the core of our purpose, we would love to hear from you.

Installations Officer - Control of Major Accidents Hazards (COMAH)

We are looking for two enthusiastic professionals to join our North West Hub Control of Major Accident Hazards (COMAH) Regulatory team as Installations Officers.

Installation Officer

If you’re part of the Environment Agency (EA), you’re part of the solution. Working with us means protecting and improving the environment for generations to come, tackling issues of national importance across a huge variety of disciplines.

Sustainable Development Programme Manager

An exciting opportunity has arisen for a driven and motivated individual to join a forward thinking and dynamic Directorate within Public Health Wales.