Scottish river quality improves

The quality of Scottish rivers continued to improve between 1985 and 1990, according to a summary of the 1990 quality survey released by the Scottish Office in March. The advance continues the trend recorded since surveys began in 1968, in contrast to the 10-year decline in England and Wales.

The National Rivers Authority's 1990 survey of water quality in England and Wales showed a 4% net decline between 1985 and 1990 (ENDS Report 201, p 6). The previous five-year survey also reported a deterioration.

In Scotland the situation is quite different (see table ). The data show a continued improvement throughout the 1980s.

In England and Wales, only 63% of river lengths were classified as good (Class 1) in 1990, and 2% were grossly polluted (Class 4). All the Scottish River Purification Board (RPB) areas have better figures than this average - even Forth, which has the most polluted rivers largely because of mine discharges. The Tay and Tweed areas have a particularly enviable record with no poor or grossly polluted lengths.

But biological indicators do not give such a rosy picture. A classification using the Institute of Freshwater Ecology's RIVPACS system puts only 78.5% of Scottish rivers in the top (Class A) category.

Biologically-based classifications will be of increasing importance in assessing the quality of Britain's rivers (ENDS Report 203, pp 10-12). The RPBs have reservations about the application of the system to Scottish rivers, and the Scottish Office is funding further research on this and the estuary classification system.

The survey covered coastal waters for the first time, and revealed that the Forth and North-East regions have the poorest quality waters. Just over 84% of coastal waters fell in the top quality class A, but 8.7% fell in the two bottom classes.

Please sign in or register to continue.

Sign in to continue reading

Having trouble signing in?

Contact Customer Support at
or call 020 8267 8120

Subscribe for full access

or Register for limited access

Already subscribe but don't have a password?
Activate your web account here