Noise nuisance and evidence

In Cooke v Adatia and others (Times Law Reports, 3 November 1988), the High Court has held that the existence of a statutory noise nuisance may be proved solely on evidence from an environmental health officer (EHO). The decision of magistrates to throw out a prosecution under section 58 of the Control of Pollution Act 1974 on the grounds that there was no other evidence to prove the nuisance was wrong. The result confirms what many would already have felt to be the legal position, but as the first High Court ruling on the point the case strengthens the hand of local authorities where evidence from affected neighbours and others is not forthcoming.

Sign in to continue

Sign in

Trouble signing in?

Reset password: Click here


Call: 020 8267 8120

Take a 30-day trial

  • Join ENDS Report now and pay nothing for your first 30-days.



Prices on request

  • Full access to for 12 months
  • Clear and accessible guidance on relevant legislation
  • Integration with ENDS Compliance Manager helping you plan ahead and ensure compliance for your organisation
  • Individual or bespoke multi-user packages available

See all benefits

Need to activate your subscription?
Already a subscriber
If you haven't already, activate your subscription here>>
Company Domain Access
If your company or university has a corporate subscription simply register your email address here to gain access