‘Not an enforcement policy’: EA faces further action for relaxing rules on sewage discharges and manure spreading

The Environment Agency (EA) has reworded two regulatory position statements (RPS) that relax the rules on sewage discharges and manure spreading but lawyers say the changes do not go far enough.

One of the statements means water firms that discharge effluent that has not been treated to levels stipulated in their environmental permits will not face enforcement action if they cannot get the chemicals needed to treat the sewage due to “the UK’s new relationship with the EU, coronavirus” or “other unavoidable supply chain failures”. 

After a backlash from lawyers, the EA this month changed the wording of the RPSs to clarify that they do not alter the legal obligations on water companies but “rather the EA’s enforcement approach if the conditions in the RPS are followed”.

Dr Justin Neal, a solicitor at not-for-profit law firm Fish Legal, said: “In the earlier version of the RPS, the EA said that it would be permissible for the water companies to discharge in breach of their permits – which was plainly an unlawful position for the EA to take. It is not surprising then that the EA has therefore responded by redrafting the RPS.” 

But he said the EA appeared to be “second guessing water company behaviour and setting out a new set of rules for when they will not normally be prosecuted”.

He said this amounted “not so much to an enforcement policy – because enforcement policies assume a crime has been committed and tell a water company what the consequences will be – but a new set of forward looking rules”. 

He said this was “not in the gift of the regulator” and that his firm was considering what steps to take next. 

Fish Legal is also concerned by the methodology being used to decide which water bodies water firms can discharge such inadequately treated sewage into. 

Under the RPS, Water Treatment Works (WWTW) in England classed as category A in water company risk assessments “should be de-prioritised in the scenario that treatment chemicals are unavailable, and all other mitigations have been exhausted”.

Neal said this “could not be right” as rather than a risk assessment being related to the actual potential impact, such as the flow measured against size of watercourse, “they rely simply on whether a river is already in poor condition”.

The second RPS, first published in August, means farmers can spread organic slurry or manure this autumn on their land, even if it exceeds the needs of the soil or crop.

The EA added a line in the RPS, again confirming that the RPS does not alter the legal obligations of operators.

Guy Linley-Adams, a solicitor for the Salmon and Trout Conservation said he was “delighted that the EA has backed off and amended its RPS”.

However he added: “What we really need to see is robust enforcement of the 2018 Farming Rules for Water.

Linley-Adams noted that farmers had been advised by the government for nearly 40 years that manure should not be spread when crops and soils do not require it.

“That’s enough of a notice period for anyone.

“Farmers have had ample time to prepare for the rules and get their manure management in order – and many have done exactly that – so it is not unreasonable to expect the EA to enforce the law against those who have not,” he said.

Related Environmental Services

Powered by ENDS Directory

Compliance Search

Discover all ENDS content in one place, including legislation summaries to keep up to date with compliance deadlines

Compliance Deadlines

Plan ahead with our Calendar feature highlighting upcoming compliance deadlines

Most-read articles

Principal Planner

Leeds is a fast growing city and the main driver of a city region with a £64.6 billion economy.

Officer 2 Environment Team x 2

Sustainable Management of Natural Resources

Environment Team Leader

If you want a role that offers variety and challenge, and to be a part of an organisation that has the sustainable management of natural resources at the core of our purpose, we would love to hear from you.

Non-Executive Member to the Office for Environmental Protection

The Department of Agriculture, Environment and Rural Affairs (DAERA) is seeking to appoint a Non-Executive Member to the Office for Environmental Protection (OEP).

Installations Officer - Control of Major Accidents Hazards (COMAH)

We are looking for two enthusiastic professionals to join our North West Hub Control of Major Accident Hazards (COMAH) Regulatory team as Installations Officers.

Installation Officer

If you’re part of the Environment Agency (EA), you’re part of the solution. Working with us means protecting and improving the environment for generations to come, tackling issues of national importance across a huge variety of disciplines.

Sustainable Development Programme Manager

An exciting opportunity has arisen for a driven and motivated individual to join a forward thinking and dynamic Directorate within Public Health Wales.